revns

High ventilation breathwork: what a 2026 study of 48 therapists found

Forty-eight Berlin mental health pros tried guided rapid breathing in the HEART study. Lueken et al. report altered states, not proof HVB treats anxiety.

revns editorial · Published November 22, 2026 · 8 min read

Lueken et al. had 48 mental-health professionals complete one HVB workshop. Pleasantness beat unpleasantness; perceived potential (68) beat risks (28)—but there was no control group.

High ventilation breathwork (HVB)—prolonged, deliberate rapid breathing in a guided group—can produce intense altered states, but a new study shows only that mental health professionals found it promising after trying it once, not that it treats depression or anxiety. In npj Mental Health Research, Ulrike Lueken and colleagues at Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin reported that 48 mental health professionals (mean age 38, 75% women) completed a standardized 50-minute breathing workshop in late 2024 and early 2025. They rated pleasantness above unpleasantness and scored perceived therapeutic potential (68.4 on a 0–100 scale) well above perceived risks (28.0). The design had no control group, so music, preparation and group support cannot be separated from the breathing itself. If you train hard and wonder whether breathwork and mental health belong in your recovery week, this paper is a safety and expectations update—not a green light to treat yourself.

TL;DR

TopicWhat Lueken et al. report (n = 48 therapists, Berlin, 2024–2025)
Intervention~30 min active connected mouth breathing + ~20 min calm breathing, facilitators, music, integration call
DesignOne-group before-and-after workshop; no randomized control
Pleasant vs unpleasantMean 60.7 vs 23.6 (0–100 VAS); pleasantness higher (t = 5.87, p < 0.001)
Altered statesBliss, unity and spiritual ratings in a range the authors compare descriptively to moderate psychedelic doses in other studies
Perceived potential vs risk68.4 vs 28.0 (0–100); potential higher (t = 9.36, p < 0.001)
Emotional breakthroughMean 51.9 (0–100); deeper breakthrough linked to higher perceived potential
Suggested fitsSocial anxiety, depression, generalized anxiety rated most promising (expert opinion only)
Suggested avoidPsychosis, bipolar, dissociative disorders, autism spectrum (expert opinion only)
Training takeawayUse slow daily breathing or easy movement for stress; treat long HVB as specialist-led, not DIY
A green daily ring beside a calm face outline, suggesting mood logs next to training load
For most training weeks, steady sleep, load and mood logs beat a one-off intense breathing session.

What is high ventilation breathwork?

High ventilation breathwork (HVB) means intentionally breathing faster and deeper than usual for a long block, usually lying down, often in a group with facilitators and music. It is distinct from the slow nasal breathing many athletes use before bed or between sets. Practices marketed as holotropic breathwork, conscious connected breathing (CCB), and some long sessions within the Wim Hof Method all sit in this fast-breathing family, though length and coaching differ.

Physiologically, sustained hyperventilation drops carbon dioxide in the blood, which can cause tingling, muscle cramps, dizziness, warmth or chills, and a racing heart—symptoms that overlap with panic attacks. The Lueken paper describes HVB as a neurometabolic intervention that can shift blood flow and autonomic tone. That is why screening matters for anyone with heart, lung or seizure risk.

For people who lift, run or compete, the relevant split is simple:

ApproachTypical useEvidence for mental health
Slow breathing (4–6 breaths per minute)Pre-sleep, pre-race calm, between intervalsStronger short-term stress data in many small trials
HVB (30+ minutes rapid connected breath)Guided workshops, research settingsEmerging; mostly small or uncontrolled studies
Hard exercise hyperventilationIntervals, metconsNormal during effort; stop if faint or chest pain

What did the 2026 therapist breathwork study do?

Lueken, Dziobek, Havenith, Schild and Daedelow ran the HEART study (High ventilation Breathwork for Therapists). They recruited mental health professionals in Berlin—mostly psychological psychotherapists in cognitive behavioral or psychodynamic training—not patients.

Who joined: 54 people started workshops; 48 completed online follow-up surveys. Exclusions included respiratory and cardiovascular disease, pregnancy, regular psychoactive or heart medicines, panic attacks in the prior three months, psychosis, bipolar disorder and past adverse breathwork reactions. About 58% had never done breathwork before; 85% had treated depression in clinic, but almost none had treated dissociative disorders.

What they did: Each four-hour workshop included preparation, a sharing circle, consent about facilitator touch, then the 50-minute breathing block. For roughly 30 minutes, participants used continuous deep mouth inhales into relaxed exhales without pauses, slightly faster than normal. For about 20 minutes, they breathed calmly as music softened. Facilitators were experienced in CCB; up to 15 participants and four facilitators attended. Workshops ran Friday or Saturday afternoons in a martial arts studio with eyeshades available.

What they measured: Before and after, therapists rated somatic and cognitive side effects, altered states (a 42-item subset of the 11-ASC scale), emotional breakthrough (Emotional Breakthrough Inventory), overall pleasantness and unpleasantness, and—critically—how they would rate HVB's psychotherapeutic potential and risks on 0–100 scales. They also marked which DSM-5 diagnoses might be suitable or unsuitable, as clinical guesses, not trial outcomes.

There was no placebo breathing group and no patient symptom data at six or twelve weeks. The ethics committee at Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin approved the protocol (application 2024-63).

Is breathwork like a moderate psychedelic dose?

Headlines compared HVB to moderate LSD or psilocybin because bliss, unity and spiritual experience scores landed in ranges similar to published psychedelic studies, in a descriptive overlay—not a head-to-head randomized trial in the same room. Visual imagery scores were weaker than classic psychedelic reports. Anxiety and impaired control stayed relatively low in this screened, motivated sample.

That comparison matters for expectations, not for prescription. Psychedelic-assisted therapy in research settings uses drug doses, medical monitoring and regulated protocols. HVB can be stopped by breathing normally, which some authors say may help people practice tolerating altered states before drug trials. None of that means you should chase a "trip" in your living room.

The paper's cautious outside commentator, Jussi Jylkkä of the University of Turku, told PsyPost the main risk for readers is confusing perceived potential with demonstrated efficacy—a similar workshop might feel promising with another ritual too.

Is breathwork safe for people who train?

In this sample, side effects were common but mostly moderate. The strongest somatic reports were muscle cramps, temperature shifts and tension or restlessness. Cognitive effects included brief disorientation and a reduced sense of reality; suicidal thoughts during the session were least reported.

Pleasantness still beat unpleasantness on average. That does not mean everyone will feel fine. About half of participants were not breathwork-naive; first-timers may react differently. The authors warn that clinical populations without prior exposure may be more vulnerable to somatic anxiety during hyperventilation.

Stop and seek urgent care for chest pain, fainting, sustained irregular heartbeat, worst-ever headache, or breathing you cannot control. Do not drive or train heavy until you feel fully normal. If you have a history of panic disorder, psychosis or bipolar disorder, this paper's clinicians rated HVB as unsuitable—that is opinion, but it aligns with exclusion criteria used in the study.

For everyday training stress, habits with clearer safety profiles include:

You can also watch resting heart rate trends in sleep tracking; hyperventilation during sport is normal, but a resting rate that stays high for days still deserves attention.

Concentric rings in soft blue and green suggesting breath cycles and calm focus
Slow, paced breathing for sleep or recovery is not the same protocol as 30 minutes of rapid hyperventilation.

Does breathwork help anxiety or depression?

This study cannot answer that. It reports therapists' opinions after one experience, not symptom change in patients.

On 0–100 scales, perceived potential (68.4) clearly exceeded risks (28.0). In exploratory regressions, older age, higher openness on the Big Five and deeper emotional breakthrough predicted higher perceived potential. The risk model did not reach significance.

When therapists rated diagnoses, social anxiety disorder, depression, somatic symptom disorder and generalized anxiety scored highest as possible indications. Schizophrenia and psychosis, dissociative disorders, bipolar disorder and autism spectrum disorder scored as contraindications. PTSD and panic disorder sat in a gray zone—the paper notes hyperventilation can mimic panic and also resemble interoceptive exposure used in panic treatment.

In free text, 68.9% of writers cited emotional processing as a potential benefit; 62.8% cited psychological destabilization as a risk theme. Again: these are views of professionals who volunteered, not outcomes.

Separate emerging trials exist—brief HVB with placebo controls, conscious connected breathing waitlist studies—but Lueken et al. stress that controlled patient trials with follow-up are still needed. revns does not offer HVB sessions and does not treat mental health conditions.

What should you do this week?

If you are healthy, curious and screened by a qualified facilitator, a structured HVB workshop may be something to discuss with your own clinician, especially if you already work with one for anxiety or trauma. If you are only trying to recover from hard training:

  1. Protect sleep and drop one hard session if mood, energy and sleep are all down for several days.
  2. Try five minutes of slow exhale-focused breathing before bed—not 30 minutes of rapid mouth breathing alone at home.
  3. Log mood 1–5 next to training for two weeks so patterns are visible.
  4. Book professional help if symptoms limit work, relationships or training for more than a couple of weeks.

Competition breath techniques (Valsalva during lifts, rhythmic breathing while running) are skill work, not psychotherapy. Keep them separate from commercial "breathwork journeys."

When to get professional help

Breathwork is not crisis care. Contact a qualified clinician or local crisis service if you:

  • Feel panic, despair or numbness most days for two weeks or more
  • Have thoughts of harming yourself or others—in the U.S., call or text 988; in the UK and Ireland, Samaritans 116 123
  • Faint, have chest pain or severe shortness of breath during or after breathing practice
  • Notice psychotic symptoms, manic surges or dissociation that feels out of control
  • Rely on intense sessions to avoid sleep, food or medical treatment

Children and adolescents were not studied here; school-age mental health needs age-appropriate care, not adult HVB protocols.

A weekly grid with some days marked hard and others easy, showing planned rest beside training
A deload week and steady breathing beat stacking extreme stress on top of heavy training.

This is general training guidance, not medical advice.

Sources

Terms in this post

revns publishes training and nutrition guidance, not medical advice. See a clinician for symptoms, injury or a medical condition. Accurate as of November 22, 2026.

Questions

Is breathwork scientifically proven?

Slow, paced breathing has solid evidence for lowering stress in the short term. Rapid group hyperventilation—high ventilation breathwork (HVB)—is newer in formal trials. Lueken et al. in npj Mental Health Research (2026) showed that 48 Berlin psychotherapists reported intense altered states after one guided session and rated potential above risk on surveys. That study did not randomize patients, did not measure symptom change weeks later, and cannot prove HVB treats depression or anxiety. Other small trials on brief HVB and mood exist, but the evidence base is still thin.

Is breathwork safe?

It depends on the type and your health. The 2026 Lueken study excluded epilepsy, heart and lung disease, pregnancy, panic attacks in the prior three months, psychosis, bipolar disorder and several medicines. During the session, muscle cramps, tingling, dizziness and a fast heart rate were common. Stop if you faint, have chest pain or cannot slow your breathing. HVB is not a home DIY technique; facilitators, screening and integration matter. For everyday training stress, slow nasal breathing or an easy walk are safer first steps.

What happens during high ventilation breathwork?

In the HEART workshop protocol, participants lay down for about 50 minutes: roughly 30 minutes of continuous deep mouth inhales linked to relaxed exhales without pauses, then about 20 minutes of calmer breathing, with music and trained facilitators present. Hyperventilation lowers carbon dioxide and can cause tingling, muscle tightness, warmth or cold, and changes in how real the world feels. In Lueken's sample, pleasantness averaged 61 on a 0–100 scale versus 24 for unpleasantness, but about half had tried breathwork before.

Does breathwork help anxiety or depression?

Not proven yet as a medical treatment. The therapists in this study guessed that social anxiety, depression and generalized anxiety might someday be suitable, while psychosis, bipolar disorder and dissociative conditions were poor fits. Those are expert opinions after one workshop, not trial results in patients. Exercise, sleep and professional care have stronger evidence for many people with anxiety or low mood. See our guides on exercise for anxiety and exercise for depression.

Is holotropic breathwork the same as Wim Hof breathing?

They share fast breathing but differ in length, setting and goals. Holotropic and conscious connected breathing often run 30 to 60 minutes or longer in groups with music and integration. The Wim Hof Method mixes shorter hyperventilation cycles with breath holds and cold exposure. The 2026 paper tested conscious connected breathing in a research-style workshop, not a full holotropic weekend. Treat each brand as its own protocol with its own risks.

Can I use breathwork instead of therapy when training feels overwhelming?

No. Logging load, sleep and mood helps you deload, but intense breathwork is not a substitute for mental health care. If low mood, panic or burnout last most days for two weeks or more, or you have thoughts of harming yourself, contact a clinician or crisis line immediately. In the U.S., call or text 988. In the UK and Ireland, Samaritans are on 116 123. revns tracks training patterns; it does not diagnose or treat conditions.

Read next

Your first brief is one entry away.

Pick an objective, say how you eat, log one thing.